---
title: "Missing or incomplete BEP: can you be excluded? | B1P Group"
description: "When a missing pre-appointment BEP leads to exclusion from an Italian tender, when to zero points, and what can still be clarified after the deadline."
url: https://www.b1pgroup.com/en/bim-news/missing-or-incomplete-pre-appointment-bep-tender-exclusion/
lang: en
published: 2026-11-20
updated: 2026-11-20
---
[All articles](https://www.b1pgroup.com/en/bim-news/)

# Can I be excluded from a tender if the pre-appointment BEP is missing or incomplete?

When a missing pre-appointment BEP leads to exclusion from an Italian tender, when to zero points, and what can still be clarified after the deadline.

**Topic**

Standards and procurement

**Published**

20 November 2026

**Author**

B1P Group editorial team

[Have a question? Write to us](https://www.b1pgroup.com/en/contact/#scrivi)

Yes, but not always. It depends on how the tender conditions treat the pre-appointment BIM execution plan (BEP), which Italian tenders call the offerta di gestione informativa (oGI). If they expressly require it as part of the technical proposal, on pain of exclusion, a missing pre-appointment BEP puts the bidder out of the tender and cannot be remedied after the deadline. If they treat it as a scoring criterion, its absence costs the points for that criterion. If they do not ask for it at all, its absence does not justify exclusion.

## What does the law say about the pre-appointment BEP?

Annex I.9 to Legislative Decree 36/2023 sets out three documents in sequence. The exchange information requirements (EIR), written by the contracting authority, set the requirements. The pre-appointment BEP is the bidder's response, submitted with the tender. The post-appointment BEP is drawn up by the successful bidder on the basis of the pre-appointment BEP, after the contract is signed and before work starts.

The law does not say what happens if the pre-appointment BEP is missing. The tender documents do: the contract notice, the tender conditions and the EIR. That is where you read whether it is required, where it has to be placed and with what consequences. For what it must contain, see [Pre-appointment BIM execution plan (BEP): contents and assessment](https://www.b1pgroup.com/en/bim-news/pre-appointment-bim-execution-plan-bep-contents-and-assessment/).

## When does a missing pre-appointment BEP lead to exclusion?

| What the tender conditions provide | If the pre-appointment BEP is missing | Can it be remedied after the deadline? |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Required in the technical proposal on pain of exclusion or inadmissibility | Exclusion | No |
| Required as an evaluation criterion, with no exclusion clause | Zero points for that criterion | No |
| Not expressly required among the documents to submit | No exclusion | Not needed |

The clearest reference is a judgment of the Italian Council of State (Consiglio di Stato, Section V, no. 6834 of 7 September 2026). The tender, published in December 2024, concerned the upgrading of an existing building. The notice did not list the pre-appointment BEP among the documents of the technical proposal, provided for exclusion only where certain documents were missing and zero points for others, and required the post-appointment BEP after the contract was signed. The court held that a mere reference to BIM or to the EIR does not make the pre-appointment BEP an essential element of the bid. If the tender documents do not expressly require it, its absence does not lead to exclusion.

The context matters, though. That tender predated 1 January 2025, when digital information management was not yet mandatory. For tenders that now fall under the obligation, the 2026 guidelines of the Ministry of Infrastructure and Transport list the pre-appointment BEP among the bidder's duties, and ANAC standard tender notice no. 2/2026 for engineering and architecture services deals with it in the evaluation of the technical proposal. It is prudent to expect an express requirement.

## What if the pre-appointment BEP is there but incomplete?

As a rule it is a matter of scoring. The evaluation panel assesses what it finds: a generic or patchy response earns few points, but stays in the tender.

It becomes a matter of exclusion when the missing content is something the tender documents classify as a minimum or essential requirement. The Council of State confirmed this in 2026 (Section V, no. 6148 of 30 July): excluding a technical proposal that omits an essential service required by the tender rules is lawful.

There is also a case that is different from the pre-appointment BEP but close to it: BIM requirements for participation. The Regional Administrative Court of Liguria (TAR Liguria, no. 944 of 4 August 2025) upheld the exclusion of a bidder that had not demonstrated the BIM requirements set by the tender conditions. Declaring them is not enough; they have to be documented.

## Can I supplement the pre-appointment BEP after the deadline?

Not as far as content is concerned. The procedure for remedying incomplete documents under art. 101 of Legislative Decree 36/2023 (soccorso istruttorio) is meant to complete administrative documents, not to add to what makes up the technical or financial proposal: equal treatment of bidders rules it out (Council of State, Section V, no. 7870 of 21 August 2023).

Two narrow openings remain. The contracting authority may ask for clarification of what is already in the bid, provided the content does not change. The bidder may ask to correct a clerical error up to the day set for opening the bids, provided the bid is not altered in substance (art. 101, paragraph 4).

In practice, what is not in the pre-appointment BEP at the deadline cannot be added later.

## What should I check before submitting the bid?

- Read the tender conditions and the EIR together: where the pre-appointment BEP has to be placed, in which format and with which signature.
- Check whether it is required on pain of exclusion or as an evaluation criterion, and how many points it carries.
- Respond to every requirement in the EIR, section by section, even if only to state how it will be met.
- Use the contracting authority's template when one is provided with the tender documents.
- Make sure the roles, certifications and experience declared can be documented.
- Upload the files early, check that they open and keep proof of what was submitted.

The [BIM tender support](https://www.b1pgroup.com/en/services/bim-tender-support/) page explains how to read the exchange information requirements.

This article describes general rules and case-law trends. The assessment of an individual case is a matter for a lawyer.

## Frequently asked questions

### If the notice does not mention the pre-appointment BEP, do I have to submit it anyway?

There is no obligation, and its absence cannot cost you exclusion. However, if the tender documents include exchange information requirements, it is worth asking the contracting authority for clarification within the time allowed, to find out whether and where it should be submitted.

### Does the risk of exclusion also exist below the €2 million threshold?

Yes, if the contracting authority has chosen to adopt digital information management even where it is not required to, as art. 43, paragraph 2 allows. In that case the rules written in the notice apply.

### Can I correct an error in a pre-appointment BEP I have already submitted?

Only if it is a clerical error, and only up to the day set for opening the bids. The correction cannot change the content of the bid.

### Does a pre-appointment BEP based on a generic template risk exclusion?

As a rule no, but it earns few points and creates contractual commitments that then have to be honoured. The risk of exclusion arises only if content required as essential is missing.

### Who can check the pre-appointment BEP before submission?

Someone who knows both the EIR and the tender conditions: the contractor's BIM manager or an external consultant. B1P Group supports contractors in reading the tender documents and checking the pre-appointment BEP before the deadline, and works with a partner law firm on the legal aspects.

### What happens if the post-appointment BEP is late after the award?

It is no longer a tender matter but a contractual one. The delay is assessed under the contract clauses, which usually set a deadline for delivering the plan.

## Sources

- Legislative Decree no. 36 of 31 March 2023: art. 43, art. 101 and Annex I.9, art. 1, paragraph 10, as amended by Legislative Decree 209/2024
- Ministry of Infrastructure and Transport, guidelines on digital information management, 2026
- ANAC, standard tender notice no. 2/2026 for engineering and architecture services
- Council of State, Section V, 7 September 2026, no. 6834
- Council of State, Section V, 30 July 2026, no. 6148
- Council of State, Section V, 21 August 2023, no. 7870
- TAR Liguria, 4 August 2025, no. 944

Further reading [BIM tender support](https://www.b1pgroup.com/en/services/bim-tender-support/)[BIM glossary](https://www.b1pgroup.com/en/bim-glossary/)

## Shall we discuss it for your project?

[Request a meeting](https://www.b1pgroup.com/en/contact/#scrivi) [Back to BIM News](https://www.b1pgroup.com/en/bim-news/)
